James McCree (1)

1956

Mr New York City - AAU, Medium, 1st
Mr New York City - AAU, Most Muscular, 1st

1957

Mr Eastern America - AAU, Overall Winner
Mr Eastern America - AAU, Medium-Tall, 1st
Mr Eastern America - AAU, Most Muscular, 1st

1958

Junior Mr America - AAU, East , 3rd