1958 Mr America - AAU
| 1 | Tom Sansone | |
| 2 | Lynn Lyman | |
| 3 | Gene Bohaty | |
| 4 | Robert Walker (1) | |
| 5 | Fred Schutz | |
| 6 | Earl Clark | |
| 7 | Vern Weaver | |
| 8 | Ray Routledge | |
| 9 | Bill Golumbick | |
| 9 | Sam Martin | |
| 9 | Chuck Sipes | |
| 12 | Joseph Baratta | |
| 13 | Roy Smith Jr | |
| 14 | Ed Bailey (1) | |
| 14 | Everett Evans | |
| 16 | Alfred Souza | |
| 17 | Gene Reid | |
| 18 | Charles Collras | |
| 19 | John Homola | |
Most Muscular | ||
| 1 | Tom Sansone | |