1959 Mr Eastern America - AAU
| Overall Winner George Orlando | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Art Ehman |
| 2 | Pete Ganios |
| 3 | Ron Covino |
| 4 | Len Bosland |
| 5 | Joe Marino (1) |
Medium-Tall | |
| 1 | Art Harris |
| 2 | Kenny Hall |
| 3 | Leo Downes |
| 4 | Steve Sedlak |
| 5 | Larry Powers |
| 6 | Peter French |
Medium | |
| 1 | Floyd Despirito |
| 2 | Johnny Maldonado |
| 3 | Giorlando Castronovo |
| 4 | Louis Santiago |
| 5 | Saul DeJesus |
| 6 | Sam Laratta |
| 7 | Frank DiGiacomo |
Short | |
| 1 | George Orlando |
| 2 | D Krell |
| 3 | John Bianculli |
| 4 | M Jarmenates |
| 5 | Richard Marotto |
Most Muscular | |
| 1 | Art Harris |