1946 Mr New York City - AAU
| Overall Winner Victor Nicoletti | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Joseph Colosimo |
| 2 | Eugene DuBuque |
| 3 | Louis Peisson |
| 4 | Fred Hacker |
Medium-Tall | |
| 1 | Howard Brodsky |
| 2 | Bernard Clark |
| 3 | Harry Watson |
| 4 | Shepard Roberts |
Medium | |
| 1 | Victor Nicoletti |
| 2 | Carmine Signore |
| 3 | John Deinbacher |
| 4 | Frank Afrunti |
Short | |
| 1 | Joseph Thaler |
| 2 | Don Colello |
| 3 | Fred Massaro |
| 4 | Philip Depasquale |