2012 Musclemania New York
| Overall Winner Kerwin Maximus | |
HeavyWeight | |
| 1 | John Jackson (3) |
Light-HeavyWeight | |
| 1 | Kerwin Maximus |
| 2 | Neil Cohn |
| 3 | Algernar Johnson |
| 4 | Leighton Edwards |
| 5 | John Leuterio |
| 6 | Michael Andrews |
MiddleWeight | |
| 1 | Devin Sullivan |
| 2 | Leon Blythe |
| 3 | Art Sullivan |
LightWeight | |
| 1 | Chaiwat |
| 2 | Marquis Villanueva |
| 3 | William Cuba |
Teen | |
| 1 | Paul Ross |
Masters | |
| 1 | Fred Borzumato |