1986 - Sandra Peluso

1987 - Karen Summers

1988 - Danielle LeRoy

1992 - Danielle LeRoy

1996 - Donna Restivo

1997 - Rosemary Cheeseman

2000 - Teressa Boodie

2001 - Teressa Boodie

2001 - Amy Hess - Figure

2002 - Cecilia Canu

2002 - Careen Connelly - Figure

2003 - Glenda Bozett

2003 - Michelle Adams - Figure

2004 - Donna Spence

2004 - Gabriella Odom - Figure

2005 - Jessica Madden - Figure

2006 - Carrie Ann Simmons

2006 - Zivile Raudoniene - Figure

2007 - Lisa Boushard

2007 - Soleivi Hernandez - Figure

2008 - Mary Elizabeth Hobbs

2008 - Katherynne Ramirez - Figure

2009 - Melissa Stocker-Betz - Figure

2010 - Nicole Borigiorno

2010 - Elizabeth Earhart - Figure

2011 - Dolly Lazarre

2011 - Kelly Keiser - Figure

2012 - Glenese Markes

2012 - Sheena Ohlig

2012 - Vanessa Rahn - Figure

2013 - Alana Shipp

2013 - Alicia Spearman

2013 - Maite Bueno - Figure

2014 - Ulla Plourde

2014 - Kelly Lyons - Figure

2015 - Gina Policastro

2015 - Deepika Chowdhury - Figure

2016 - Christina Wilson

2016 - Sandra Oquendo - Figure

2017 - Ivie Rhein

2017 - Nicole Zenobia Graham - Figure

2018 - Melissa Scott

2018 - Mackenzie Moratto - Figure

2019 - Lauren Dallessandro

2019 - Kathleen Judy - Figure

2021 - Reina Gonzalez - Figure