1981 - Deborah Diana

1982 - Stella Martinez

1983 - Lori Bowen

1984 - Clare Furr

1985 - Dona Oliviera

1986 - Laura Creavalle

1987 - Jackie Paisley

1988 - Dorothy Herndon

1989 - Debbie McKnight

1990 - Shelley Beattie

1991 - Nancy Lewis

1992 - Tazzie Colomb

1993 - Denise Rutkowski

1994 - Danielle LeRoy

1995 - Valerie Gangi

1996 - Clifta Coulter

1997 - Lesa Lewis

1998 - Iris Kyle

1999 - Thresa Bostick

2000 - Jennifer McVicar

2001 - Mah-Ann Mendoza

2002 - Rosemary Jennings

2003 - Bonny Priest

2004 - Carrie Ledford

2005 - Amanda Dunbar

2005 - Michelle Flake - Figure

2006 - Heather Armbrust

2006 - Paola Almerico - Figure

2006 - Simona Douglas - Figure

2007 - Jennifer Sedia

2007 - Catherine Anderson - Figure

2008 - Isabelle Turell

2008 - Amy Lee Martin - Figure

2009 - Angie Salvagno

2009 - Listy Allen - Figure

2010 - Sarah Hayes

2010 - Courtney West - Figure

2011 - Sheilahe Brown

2011 - Robyn Mentgen

2011 - Wendy Fortino - Figure

2012 - Tierany Chertien

2012 - Samantha Hill

2013 - Shannon Courtney

2013 - Maria Rita Penteado

2013 - Latorya Neisha Watts - Figure

2014 - Aleesha Young

2014 - Tonya Hooker

2014 - Angela Yamashita - Figure

2015 - Billie Cavalier

2015 - Kayce Gorman - Figure

2016 - Jessica Martin

2016 - Tonya Wheatfall - Figure

2017 - Courtney Rheams

2017 - Nicole Wolf - Figure

2018 - Ashlynn Richardson

2018 - Diana Cadena - Figure

2019 - Dee Joseph

2019 - Macey Toney

2019 - Ajanel Williams - Figure

2020 - Layla Ikahihifo

2020 - Stephanie Gibson - Figure