1986 Masters Mr America - AAU
| Overall Winner Butch Fairchild | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Thomas Willert |
| 2 | John Kelly |
| 3 | David Sigloch |
| 4 | Bill Mortimer |
| 5 | Steve Scialia |
Medium-Tall | |
| 1 | Carl Smith |
| 2 | Bob Sharp |
| 3 | Steve Uglay |
| 4 | Ron Sell |
| 5 | James Williams (2) |
Medium | |
| 1 | Keith Kephart |
| 2 | Richard Dawid |
| 3 | Gene Gregorits |
| 4 | Robert Bashore |
| 5 | Ron Crocco |
Short | |
| 1 | Butch Fairchild |
| 2 | Dennis Bello |
| 3 | Charles Trimarco Jr |
| 4 | Wiley Owens |
| 5 | Claude Rigon |