1991 Masters Mr America - AAU
| Overall Winner Frank Capallupo | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Frank Gyalog |
| 2 | David Brown (1) |
| 3 | Larry Mayer |
| 4 | Bill Murray |
| 5 | Lance Cotton |
| 6 | James Kastel |
| 7 | Joe Dodd |
| 8 | Doug Burgess |
| 9 | Norman Gibson |
| 10 | Steve Mazzola |
Medium | |
| 1 | Richard Byrd |
| 2 | Tom Owen |
| 3 | Robert Reis |
| 4 | Ed Flanders |
| 5 | Jack Pogue |
| 6 | Cliff Dawson |
| 7 | Jack Burroughs |
| 8 | Sam Bryant |
| 9 | Don Williams |
| 10 | Frank Mueller |
Short | |
| 1 | Frank Capallupo |
| 2 | Gary Ayars |
| 3 | Ron Crocco |
| 4 | Gene Gregorits |
| 5 | Robert Bashore |
| 6 | Don Cioffi |
| 7 | Harry Silas |
| 8 | Joe Parella |
| 9 | T J Mulvey |
Masters 50+ | |
| 1 | Wiley Owens |
| 2 | Jim Batick |
| 3 | Bob Thompson (1) |
| 4 | Louis Leigh |
| 5 | Harold Collins |
| 6 | Jack Burkett |
| 7 | Carl Adams |
| 8 | James Taylor (1) |
| 9 | Joe Lazzaro (1) |
| 10 | Fred Hobby |
| 11 | Robert Riley |
| 12 | Ronald Damon |
| 13 | Frank Guest |
| 14 | Howard Hyatt |