1996 Masters Mr America - AAU
| Overall Winner Karl Herkert | |
Masters 40+ Tall | |
| 1 | Charles Moss |
| 2 | Charles Rogers |
| 3 | Don Ferrell |
| 4 | Jack Abrams |
Masters 40+ Medium | |
| 1 | Eugene Hawkins |
| 2 | John Werner |
| 3 | Gerald Donato |
| DQ | Doug Goad |
Masters 40+ Short | |
| 1 | Karl Herkert |
| 2 | James Eason |
| 3 | Steve Stewart (1) |
| 4 | Oscar Hawkins |
| 5 | Rick Conte |
| 6 | Alonzo Trimiew |
| 7 | Kenneth Ford |
| DQ | Joel Ingle |
Masters 50+ Overall Winner Nance Maitland | |
Masters 50+ Tall | |
| 1 | David John Wilson |
| 2 | David Sigloch |
| 3 | Jim Hickham |
| 4 | Bill Mortimer |
Masters 50+ Short | |
| 1 | Nance Maitland |
| 2 | William Womack |
| 3 | James Taylor (1) |
| 4 | Garrett Albert |
| 5 | Dominick Duche |
| 6 | Carl Kristenson |
Masters 60+ Overall Winner John Mangini | |
Masters 60+ Tall | |
| 1 | Jack King (1) |
| 2 | Chuck Avery |
| 3 | Len Bosland |
| 4 | Ralph DeBeufre |
Masters 60+ Short | |
| 1 | John Mangini |
| 2 | Paul Hanson |
| 3 | Reggie Faust |
| 4 | Raymond Burns |