1986 Ms America - AAU
| Overall Winner Connie McCloskey | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Teresa Nordaby |
| 2 | Karin Mitchell |
| 3 | Debra Poston |
| 4 | Tammy Baltz |
| 5 | Sandra Barrett-Walker |
| 6 | Cynthia Albrecht |
| 7 | Lisa Fortunato |
| 8 | Nitika Harris |
| 9 | Karen McCoy (1) |
| 10 | Sheilahe Brown |
Medium | |
| 1 | Cathy Butler |
| 2 | Linda WoođHoyte |
| 3 | Margo Allen Weil |
| 4 | Linda Doss |
| 5 | Judi Benz |
| 6 | Susie White |
| 7 | Mary Claire Smerda |
| 8 | Christine Cormier |
| 9 | Jane Schwenker |
| 10 | Diana Bona |
| 11 | Skye WilđDixon |
| 12 | Miriam Chiaverini |
Short | |
| 1 | Connie McCloskey |
| 2 | Jenny Baltimore |
| 3 | Claudia Mountfort |
| 4 | Tiny Robertson |
| 5 | Sandy Perham |