2004 Olympus Natural - NMA
| Overall Winner Carmelo Lopez | |
HeavyWeight | |
| 1 | Josh Trentine |
| 2 | Frank Consola |
| 3 | John Turnbull |
MiddleWeight | |
| 1 | Sean Tydings |
| 2 | Mark Mammarella |
| 3 | Dan Iatomasi |
LightWeight | |
| 1 | Carmelo Lopez |
| 2 | Fred Suttle |
| 3 | Joe Przybyla |
| 4 | Rob Weinrib |
| 5 | Geoff Heusinger |
Teen | |
| 1 | Dan Iatomasi |
| 2 | Matt Robson |
Masters | |
| 1 | Rob Weinrib |
| 2 | Dominic Venditti |
| 3 | Bill Kramer |
| 4 | Ralph Della Rocco |
Professional | |
| 1 | Paul Iatomasi Sr |
| 2 | Craig Chodak |
| 3 | Robert Johnson (3) |