2009 Olympus Natural - NMA
| Overall Winner Jason Hanna | |
HeavyWeight | |
| 1 | Jason Hanna |
| 2 | George West |
| 3 | Will Smith (3) |
| 4 | Nico Ferrara |
Light-HeavyWeight | |
| 1 | Shawn Casella |
| 2 | Trevor King |
| 3 | Andre Taibbi |
MiddleWeight | |
| 1 | Chris Lawrence |
| 2 | Sean Campbell |
| 3 | Jess Taylor |
| 4 | Eric Osmanski |
| 5 | Kuang Chen |
| 6 | Eugene Ring |
LightWeight | |
| 1 | Jason Brown (2) |
| 2 | Paul Jacoby |
| 3 | Pasquale Sacco |
Teen | |
| 1 | Nico Ferrara |
Masters 40+ | |
| 1 | Chris Lawrence |
| 2 | Shawn Casella |
| 3 | Sheldon Bivens |
| 4 | Will Smith (3) |
| 5 | Lou Pullano |
| 6 | Mark Solomon |
Masters 50+ | |
| 1 | Sheldon Bivens |
| 2 | Mark Solomon |
| 3 | Pasquale Sacco |
Masters 60+ | |
| 1 | Pasquale Sacco |