1958 Teen Mr America - AAU
| 1 | John Gourgott |
| 2 | Charles Schell |
| 3 | Edward Lazzaro |
| 4 | Lennell Sheperd |
| 5 | Ronnie Russell |
| 6 | Aaron Billups |
| 7 | Fred Becker |
| 8 | John Kapsal |
| 9 | Jerry Doettrel |
| 10 | Alton Frix |
| 11 | Bruce Geist |
| 12 | Larry Williams (1) |
| 13 | Thomas Riordan |
| 14 | George Halliburton |
| 15 | Arnold Brower |
| 16 | Andrew Muir |
| 17 | Peter Tobias |
| 18 | Ted Brown |
| 19 | Richard Denison |