1996 Teen Mr America - AAU
| Overall Winner Jay Jaillett | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Chris Morley |
| 2 | Nelson Labaredas |
| 3 | Richard Nawazelski |
| 4 | Ray DiBartolomeo |
| 5 | Edward Anderson (1) |
Short | |
| 1 | Jay Jaillett |
| 2 | Justin Leonard |
| 3 | Jonathan Brandon |
| 4 | Nicholas Ortego |
| 5 | Gary Warren |
| DQ | Kurt Eberly |