1982 - Lee Haney

1983 - Rich Gaspari

1984 - Pat Lanzillo

1986 - Eddie Robinson (1)

1987 - Bob Cicherillo

1988 - Porter Cottrell

1989 - Kyle Norris

1990 - Robert Rothrock

1991 - Paul Demayo

1992 - Ken Castagnoli

1993 - Rod Ketchens

1994 - Jose Pepi Feliu

1995 - Willie Stallings

1996 - Robert Russo

1997 - Kenneth Brown

1998 - Kevin English

1999 - Robert Washington

2000 - Albert Foster

2001 - Thomas Rieke

2002 - Michael Ergas

2003 - Jimmy Canyon

2004 - Steve McLeod (2)

2005 - Phil Heath

2006 - Evan Centopani

2007 - Michael Lockett

2008 - Sean Allan

2009 - Jonathan DeLaRosa

2010 - Matthew Lowden

2011 - Kevin Jordan

2012 - Anthony Pasquale

2013 - Allen Richards

2014 - Dorian Haywood

2015 - Christian Salcedo

2016 - Derek Lunsford

2017 - Brandon Mims

2018 - Dectric Lewis

2019 - Nathan Epler