1982 - Dinise MacPhail

1983 - Deborah Konnan-Jacobs

1984 - Joanna Carricator

1985 - Gillian Hodge

1986 - Marilynn Carle

1987 - Laurie Hamilton

1988 - Laurie Stark

1989 - Stephanie Venters

1990 - Etta Timmerman

1991 - Jane O'Brien

1992 - Vicky Pitchford

1993 - Yvonne Vasquez

1994 - Alana Crespo

1995 - Renee O'Neill

1996 - Tammy Simpson

1997 - Kelly McCloskey

1998 - Anita Ramsey

1999 - Sharon Robelle

2000 - Sherry Michel

2001 - Loretta Riley

2001 - Marlene Harden - Figure

2002 - Norma Nieves

2002 - Jana Knezevic - Figure

2003 - Stephanie Kessler

2003 - Krista Smith - Figure

2004 - Annette Lopez

2004 - Leslie Stefano - Figure

2005 - Debbie Laszewski

2005 - Ava Cowan - Figure

2006 - Nekole Hamrick

2006 - Amy Thompson - Figure

2007 - Anastasia Lea Maillard

2007 - Christina Morales - Figure

2008 - Ashalyn Porter

2009 - Kris Clark

2009 - Amanda Martz - Figure

2010 - Beth Wachter

2011 - Wendy Watson

2012 - Kristy McGrael

2012 - Dolly Lazarre

2012 - Tiffany Sloss - Figure

2013 - Gabriela Quiros

2013 - Angie Garcia - Figure

2014 - April Cosimano

2014 - Jennifer Freeman - Figure

2015 - Julianne Trebing

2016 - Randi Stockdill

2016 - Yordana Alayon - Figure

2017 - Kiera Lemmer

2017 - Kannel Landau - Figure

2018 - Maria Bouchalova

2018 - Rita Sequeira - Figure

2019 - Christina Wilson

2019 - Shannon Williams - Figure